Best foreclosure attorneys in Plant City
These are the ten highest-scoring foreclosure attorneys serving Plant City, ranked by our earned composite score (see methodology), which weighs rating, review volume, recency, and sentiment together rather than star rating alone.
This list covers general foreclosure-related legal help across estate, real estate, and bankruptcy-adjacent practices. If you want firms ranked specifically on foreclosure defense litigation, see our best foreclosure defense list.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to foreclosure attorney, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Byrd & Barnhill, P.L. | 83 | 4.7 (118) | — | All-round pick with the deepest track record |
| 2 | The Tancredo Law Firm, P.A. | 82 | 4.8 (55) | — | Fast intake and responsive communication |
| 3 | Sperry Law Firm | 74 | 5 (16) | — | Real estate and business-side legal work |
| 4 | Trinkle Redman P.A. | 65 | 4.5 (16) | — | Long-established firm for real estate and estate planning |
| 5 | The Law Office of Keith Will Wynne, Esq. | 59 | 3.9 (11) | — | Bankruptcy-adjacent foreclosure exit strategies |
| 6 | Bay Area Legal Services | 59 | 3.6 (16) | — | Multi-county reach for straightforward cases |
| 7 | Dwyer, John A | 56 | 4.2 (10) | — | Estate planning paired with property protection |
| 8 | David H Galloway PA Attorney | 51 | 5 (3) | — | Small firm with a loyal, long-tenured following |
| 9 | Law Office of Herman and Herman | 51 | 5 (1) | — | Courtroom advocacy experience |
| 10 | Charles S. White PA | 50 | 3.7 (11) | — | Real estate and title work with notary service |
Ranked picks
Byrd & Barnhill, P.L.
Why it ranks first
Byrd & Barnhill posts the highest composite score on this list, built on 118 reviews and a 4.7 rating, which is a large and high-confidence sample for a Plant City firm. Johnnie Byrd is repeatedly credited with turning stressful estate, trust, and probate situations into manageable processes with clear, steady communication.
Pros
- Knowledgeable and thorough on complex matters
- Compassionate with clients going through loss or hardship
- Clear communication and consistent updates
- Patient, plain-language guidance through the process
Watch out: At least one reviewer felt brushed off when their matter fell outside the firm's usual scope.
Services: real estate law, free consultation, spanish speaking, foreclosure defense
The Tancredo Law Firm, P.A.
Why it ranks second
The Tancredo Law Firm sits just behind the top spot with a 4.8 rating across 55 reviews, and clients single out Chris Tancredo's team for honest, transparent counsel rather than sales talk. Staff members Teagan and Jamie get named repeatedly for same-day or next-morning intake and staying reachable by text and phone.
Pros
- 27+ years in practice
- Same-day or next-morning case intake
- Reachable staff via text and phone
- Honest, straight-talk assessment of outcomes
Watch out: A few reviewers noted occasional lapses on follow-up calls.
Services: foreclosure defense, bankruptcy law, real estate law, consumer protection law
Sperry Law Firm
Why it ranks third
Sperry Law Firm holds a perfect 5.0 rating across 16 reviews, with clients naming several staff members (Michelle, Felicia, Bruce, Benjamin, Cheri) for competence in real estate and corporate documentation built over years of repeat business. The sample is smaller than the top two firms, so treat the score as promising but still developing.
Pros
- Perfect rating across all 16 reviews on file
- Transparent about fees and costs upfront
- Named staff with long-term repeat clients
- Handles both business and personal legal needs
Services: real estate law, consumer protection law, free consultation, spanish speaking
Trinkle Redman P.A.
Why it ranks fourth
Trinkle Redman has operated since 1928 and clients describe Daniel Coton and the team as friendly and skilled across real estate and estate planning matters over many years. Review volume is modest, but the sentiment is consistently favorable aside from one notable access complaint.
Pros
- Trusted, long-established firm (since 1928)
- Personable, easy-to-work-with attorneys
- Handles multiple practice areas
- Long-term family trust built over decades
Watch out: One reviewer had significant trouble reaching the office by phone and ran into scheduling problems.
Services: foreclosure defense, real estate law, free consultation, spanish speaking
The Law Office of Keith Will Wynne, Esq.
Why it ranks fifth
Keith Will Wynne draws praise for empathy and quick responsiveness, particularly on bankruptcy and divorce matters that often intersect with foreclosure timelines, and offers a free consultation with a Spanish-speaking option. Sentiment is mixed overall: older reviews describe incomplete work and lost paperwork, though recent five-star reviews suggest things have improved.
Pros
- Free consultation available
- Spanish-speaking option
- 7-day availability
- Specializes in bankruptcy exit strategies
Watch out: Older reviews mention incomplete work, lost paperwork, and unexpected extra fees; case overload has been a recurring theme.
Services: foreclosure defense, bankruptcy law, free consultation, real estate law
Bay Area Legal Services
Why it ranks sixth
Bay Area Legal Services operates across multiple counties and locations, and satisfied clients cite clear, practical guidance with fast case resolution. The review base is small and split, with phone access being the main sore point for dissatisfied callers.
Pros
- Clear, practical legal guidance
- Fast case handling for straightforward matters
- Professional attorneys once you reach them
- Multiple locations across counties
Watch out: Phone lines reportedly drop or go unanswered, and some callers describe staff as dismissive.
Services: free consultation, real estate law, foreclosure defense, consumer protection law
Dwyer, John A
Why it ranks seventh
John Dwyer earns praise for efficient, professional work on trusts, wills, and Lady Bird Deeds, which can factor into protecting property ahead of a foreclosure situation. Service appears inconsistent: two one-star reviews describe missed calls and feeling unprepared for court on family law matters.
Pros
- Knowledgeable on trusts and estate planning
- Efficient turnaround on documents
- Works alongside paralegal Lynn
- Free consultation offered
Watch out: Some reviewers report unreturned calls and inadequate preparation ahead of court dates.
Services: bankruptcy law, foreclosure defense, real estate law, consumer protection law
David H Galloway PA Attorney
Why it ranks eighth
David H Galloway PA has only three reviews on record, but they span a decade and are consistently positive, with clients crediting the staff for staying professional and personable through a transition after the founding attorney's passing. Treat the score as low-confidence given the small sample.
Pros
- Professional and friendly staff
- Reliable continuity through firm transition
Watch out: Only three reviews on file, so there is limited evidence to judge consistency.
Services: real estate law, free consultation, spanish speaking, foreclosure defense
Law Office of Herman and Herman
Why it ranks ninth
Law Office of Herman and Herman has just one review on record, but it describes over 40 years in practice and a courtroom win, which points to real litigation experience. This is the lowest-confidence entry on the list simply due to volume of feedback.
Pros
- Over 40 years in practice
- Courtroom experience and legal strategy
Watch out: Only one review is available, so there is very limited evidence to evaluate day-to-day service.
Services: real estate law, free consultation, spanish speaking, foreclosure defense
Charles S. White PA
Why it ranks tenth
Charles S. White PA is known for thorough real estate and title work, including mobile notary services, which can matter when property paperwork is tied up in a foreclosure case. Feedback is mixed, with satisfied clients praising responsiveness during active cases and others citing billing and communication frustrations.
Pros
- Thorough real estate and title work
- Mobile notary services offered
- Responsive once a case is active
- Compassionate, professional staff by some accounts
Watch out: Some reviewers report poor phone communication and unexpected billing.
Services: real estate law, foreclosure defense, free consultation, spanish speaking